The 12 Best Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge You shouldn’t Miss!

Exploring new culinary experiences can be a delightful adventure, even if it means venturing out to the latest and most popular Italian restaurants in Pigeon Forge. Are you looking for the best Italian Restaurant in Pigeon Forge? We’ve got you covered! Whether you’re drawn to tantalizing dishes that tickle your fantasy, or you’ve received rave recommendations from friends and colleagues, the world of Italian cuisine in Pigeon Forge is sure to captivate your taste buds.

Pigeon Forge boasts a diverse range of dining options, catering to various preferences, be it the amazing upscale Italian dining, a quick yet satisfying meal, or the rich flavors of authentic Italian cuisine. With an array of establishments to choose from, including traditional Italian eateries and contemporary farm-to-table restaurants, there’s something to satiate every palate in the heart of Pigeon Forge.

12 Best Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge

1. Johnny Carino’s

Johnny Carino’s is a classic Italian chain restaurant serving familiar and modern fares in a family-friendly setting. This restaurant isn’t just a top pick for classic Italian cuisine but for family gatherings and other group dining. The restaurant’s highlights include authentic Italian food, fast service, a great beer selection, an amazing cocktail and an impressive wine selection. The menu in Johnny’s Carino’s covers options like comfort food, vegetarian options, and small plates. You can visit for lunch and dinner, either dining in or going for a takeaway option.

The popular dishes at Johnny Carino’s include Italian Nachos, classic chicken parmesan, chicken marsala, spaghetti, mozzarella sticks, grilled chicken bowtie festival, chicken Alfredo, spicy shrimp and chicken, lobster Ravioli, shrimp scampi, and lemon rosemary chicken. Johnny Carino’s also serves handcrafted Pizza, salads, chicken specialties, seafood, family platters, and desserts.

2. Ristorante Della Santina

Ristorante Della Santina is a romantic and cozy spot for enjoying Italian fares, including meat dishes, pasta, seafood, and desserts. The restaurant presents an unpretentious dining setting with a cool and relaxing atmosphere. The service here is fast, and the staff is quite friendly. The food is great, and they serve only authentic Italian dishes. The menu covers homemade soup, Antipasti, pasta, Rosticceria, Caffe, and small plates. Popular dishes are Lasana Boloanese, bruschetta, Focaccia, eggplant parmesan, scallops, Calamari frritti, Ravioli, shrimp Alfredo, and New Zealand lamb chops. Other amazing dishes you might want to try include their Minestrone soup, eggplant Parmigiana, chicken fettuccine, Rigatoni, and Italian salad.

3. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

If you are looking for the best Italian restaurant in Pigeon Forge that has it all: great food, amazing service, and a great environment, look no further than Olive Garden Italian Restaurant. This restaurant is a lively, family-friendly chain featuring Italian treats such as pasta and salads. Their offerings cover quick bites, vegan options, vegetarian plates, healthy options, cocktails, wines, beers, coffee, and spirits. Guests get to enjoy an abundance of homemade food, including their famous never-ending first course of freshly baked breadsticks and homemade soups or garden fresh salad.

You will find delicious varieties of classic Italian favorites like Tour of Italy, chicken Parmigiana, or the people’s favorite, the Fettuccine Alfredo. Olive Garden Italian restaurant is all about family and friends coming together to enjoy the true taste of Italian cuisine. So whether you are visiting with family, a friend, or a loved one, you are sure to have a memorable dining in an Olive Garden Italian restaurant.

4. Gondolier Italian restaurant

Italian restaurants are known for their great expertise in Pizza, but some pizzas offer more than just good taste. If you want to have a unique pizza experience, try Gondolier Italian restaurant.

This restaurant is quite popular for its variety of delicious Pizzas made with care and attention. They have traditional pizza options like the house special pizza, Hungry meat-eaters pizza, BBQ chicken pizza, Trio vegetarian pizza, Tijuana hot pizza, and lots more.

The white pizza option covers pizzas like the Margarita pizza, Kalamationo pizza, Florentine pizza, Broccoli pizza, and lots of other diet and health-based Pizza. Though you might want to visit Gondolier Italian restaurant for their amazing Pizza, do not forget to try their amazing chicken wings, strombolis, sandwiches, and homemade Italian dinner.

The restaurant also serves pasta, chicken plates, seafood, and kid’s menu. The popular dishes at Gondolier Italian restaurant you might want to try include Calzone, Lasgane, Gyro plates, Baklava cheesecake, chicken parmigina, and Stromboli.

5. Seasons 101

If you are looking for a trendy Italian restaurant in Pigeon Forge with an effective service system, check out The Season 101. This restaurant offers comfort food, small plates, and vegetarian options. Their menu covers options like a rack of lamb, sesame seared Ahi Tuna, fried green tomatoes, red velvet cheesecake, black Angus filet Mignon, Flatbread, and many regular and unique Italian plates. Season 101 offers homemade soups, such as creamy tomato basil bisque, and the chef’s daily creations, which they use the finest ingredients to prepare. The appetizers and small plates feature treats like Tempera coconut wild gulf coast shrimp and Brie en route.

The main deal, which is the chef’s signature culinary offerings, covers delicacies like Wilk Alaskan salom, Parmesan Encrusted Barramundi, Beef Madalions, and lots more. Highlights of Seasons 101 include a fireplace, great cocktail and beer selection, rooftop seating, an impressive wine list, and great coffee and dessert.

6. New York Pizza and Pasta

New York Pizza and Pasta is another good place to enjoy some Italian cuisine in Pigeon Forge. This restaurant features a no-frills counter dolling out Jumbo slices along with subs, hot dogs, and other comfort eats. The New York Pizza and Pasta is not your typical Italian restaurant, but it is a good place to enjoy some comfort like hot subs, French fries, hot dogs, and Pizza, including pasta, Calzones, and Stromboli.

For their pasta option, New York Pizza and Pasta offer baked manicotti, Chicken parmesan, baked spaghetti, and stuffed shells. The pizza includes different types, including veggie treats, meat lovers, and personal pans. There is also something for the kids in New York: Pizza and pasta. Other featured item on the menu includes Philly cheese steak, loaded nachos, and chicken strip dinner.

 7. Solorzanos Pizzeria

Solorzanos Pizzeria prides itself on delivering the true taste of Italy. Their recipes are crafted with care and feature high-quality, fresh ingredients. From their savory sauces to their hand-tossed pizza dough, every element reflects the authenticity of Italian cuisine. The restaurant offers a diverse menu that caters to a wide range of Italian food enthusiasts. Whether you’re a fan of classic pasta dishes like Spaghetti Bolognese or you prefer a perfectly cooked Margherita pizza, there’s something for everyone.

One of the standout features of Solorzans Pizzeria is its wood-fired pizza oven. The smoky and crispy crust, combined with a variety of fresh toppings, creates a memorable pizza experience that many consider the best in Pigeon Forge. Solorzans Pizzeria provides a cozy and inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience. The rustic decor, warm lighting, and friendly staff make you feel like you’re dining in a charming Italian trattoria.

8. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria – Pigeon Forge

Big Daddy’s is known for its wood-fired pizzas that come out with a crispy crust and delicious toppings. They offer a variety of specialty pizzas and the option to build your own. The restaurant is designed to cater to families and groups. The casual and welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal place to bring kids and enjoy a relaxed meal.

While Pizza is their specialty, Big Daddy’s also offers a diverse menu that includes salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, and appetizers. This ensures there’s something for everyone in your party, even if they’re not in the mood for Pizza.

The restaurant takes pride in using fresh and high-quality ingredients to craft its dishes, ensuring a flavorful and satisfying dining experience. Big Daddy’s has large screens where you can catch live sports events while enjoying your meal, making it a great spot for sports enthusiasts.

Also, Read Satisfy Your Cravings: Discover the 12 Top Restaurants in Phoenixville, VA!

9. J. Del’s Pizza

At J. Del’s Pizza, the culinary team takes pride in crafting pizzas that pay homage to the rich and authentic flavors of Italy. Every Pizza is a symphony of fresh, high-quality ingredients, homemade sauces, and a perfectly baked crust that transports you straight to the heart of Naples. At the same time, Pizza is the main dish.

J. Del’s offers a diverse menu to cater to a variety of tastes. From classic Margherita and Pepperoni to creative specialty pies, there’s something for everyone, including pasta dishes, fresh salads, and appetizers that tantalize the palate. The kitchen at J. Del’s is a testament to handcrafted excellence. Every Pizza is meticulously prepared with attention to detail, ensuring a harmonious blend of flavors and textures in every bite.

Step inside J. Del’s, and you’re welcomed into a warm and inviting atmosphere that encourages relaxation and enjoyment. Whether you’re on a date night, celebrating with family, or having a casual meal with friends, the ambiance sets the stage for a memorable dining experience.

10. Papa Leone’s Pizzeria

Papa Leone’s Pizzeria is your ticket to a taste of Italy. Their recipes pay homage to the rich culinary heritage of Italy, with every dish bursting with authentic flavors and made using high-quality, imported Italian ingredients. At the heart of Papa Leone’s menu is its mouthwatering selection of pizzas. From classic Margherita to creative gourmet creations, their pizzas are crafted with a perfect balance of fresh toppings, savory sauces, and a perfectly baked crust. It’s no wonder locals and visitors alike rave about their pizza offerings. While Pizza is the star, Papa Leone’s offers a diverse menu to cater to all tastes. Explore a range of pasta dishes, fresh salads, appetizers, and delectable Italian desserts, ensuring there’s something for every member of your dining party.

11. Nino’s Pizzeria and Eatery

Nino’s Pizzeria and Eatery is a well-loved and popular dining establishment known for its delicious Italian cuisine and inviting atmosphere. Nino’s is renowned for its mouthwatering pizzas. Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita or you prefer inventive gourmet combinations, their pizzas feature a harmonious blend of fresh toppings, flavorful sauces, and perfectly baked crusts. It’s no wonder locals and visitors alike sing praises for their pizzas. While Pizza is a standout, Nino’s menu offers an array of choices. From delectable pasta dishes and crisp salads to tempting appetizers and delectable desserts, there’s something to please every palate.

The talented chefs at Nino’s take great pride in their craft. Every dish is prepared with meticulous attention to detail, ensuring each bite is a celebration of taste and texture. Nino’s is known for its family-friendly environment, offering a children’s menu that ensures young diners are well-catered to.

The attentive and friendly staff at Nino’s is committed to making your dining experience exceptional. They are knowledgeable about the menu and are happy to accommodate dietary preferences.

12. Luigi’s Pizzeria

Luigi’s Pizzeria is a popular pizza restaurant offering basic Italian fare served in a relaxed, rustic pizza parlor with TVs, a fireplace, and patio seating. The restaurant offers dine-in, delivery, takeaway, and outdoor seating to ensure that you get to enjoy Luigi’s food anywhere, whether in the restaurant or at home. Luigi’s Pizzeria is not just a trendy spot for Pizza; they are also known for their amazing Italian food and vegetarian options. They serve wings, salads, BYo pizza, Stromboli and calzone, Gyros and subs, spaghetti, baked entrees, desserts, and kids’ options like chicken tenders, cheese pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, and lots more. The Gyros and subs cover options like ham and cheese, meatball parmigiana sub, steak and cheese sub, Italian sub, and gyro sub. Stromboli and Calzone serve varieties of chicken plates, Meatlovers calzone, and vegetarian Calone. The restaurant’s specialties, like BBQ chicken pizza, Buffalo chicken pizza, chicken parmigiana pizza, and King Shrimp pizza, are a must-have.

Conclusion

Trying new eateries can be a delightful experience, especially with our trusted, curated list of the top 12 restaurants in Pigeon Forge. The diversity of dining options featured in this list offers something for everyone, making it a rewarding journey for food lovers. So, don’t hesitate to embark on this culinary adventure and savor the delicious offerings these places have to offer.